Multiple Choice Monday: Will Mike Scioscia Ever Learn to Fill Out a Lineup Card?

We’ve seen Mike Scioscia cook up some bizarre lineups in his day, but he seems to have gone off the deep end in the last week by moving Bobby Abreu into the cleanup role, keeping Erick Aybar in the top of the order and continuing to bury Mark Trumbo in the bottom third of the lineup.  We had all hoped his lineup decision making skills would eventually improve, but now I am starting to worry that Scioscia might have early on-set Alzheimer’s setting in with the choices he is making.  Now I can’t help but wonder if there will ever come a day when Scioscia wises up to simple stats like OBP and crafts a batting order that doesn’t cause the entire fanbase to pull its collective hair out.

Sounds like a great poll question for this week: Will Mike Scioscia ever learn to fill out a logical lineup?

Angels lineup card

Seen here, the rare Angel lineup with Napoli batting cleanup.

Time to vote!

  1. We should all just shut up and trust Scioscia.  His lineups may not make sense to us, but he is the guy who has turned the Angels into a top club that contends almost every year, so, maybe he knows better than us.
  2. Give him a break, with the players he has at his disposal, there isn’t a lineup that anyone could create that wouldn’t look stupid.
  3. No, Scioscia has long shown the fatal flaw of placing too much faith in his veterans, even when they aren’t performing, and too little faith in sabermetrics.
  4. Are you kidding?  These crazy lineups will never end.  Let’s not forget that we are talking about a guy who refuses to bench Jeff Mathis.
  5. Fire Tony Reagins!  I don’t know why, but everything seems to be Reagins’ fault, so blame him here.

To place your vote, simply find the Poll of the Week in the gray sidebar to the right.

Garrett Wilson

About Garrett Wilson

Garrett Wilson is the founder and Supreme Overlord of and editor at The Outside Corner. He's an Ivy League graduate, but not from one of the impressive ones. You shouldn't make him angry. You wouldn't like him when he is angry.